Baby, you can tax my car (but my bicycle, really?)

headlightThe local street and road network in the United States is supported by general taxes, like property taxes, as well as gas taxes. Thus, the relatively few adults who walk and/or ride bicycles but don’t drive cars still pay for roads. Even people who rent, rather than own, their living quarters help pay for the right of way because their landlords pay property taxes, at least in part, with rental income.

Despite that, a timeless complaint is that people who ride bicycles don’t pay their way because they don’t pay gas taxes. An equally valid complaint might be that children who enjoy swingsets don’t pay their way because they don’t pay airline baggage fees.

Let’s set aside the explicit belief here that the use of a bicycle–a non-polluting transportation resource for everyone, including those too young or old to drive–should be subject to a specific tax. That kind of thinking is just a pedal stroke away from George Harrison’s claim that the British government wanted nothing less than to tax his feet.

What’s more interesting is that, with some exceptions, state gas taxes may not be that big a burden for the average person who drives, mainly because rates haven’t increased in years. Mind you, this isn’t a plea to raise gas taxes; it hasn’t escaped me that Missouri has pretty nice roads despite significantly lower gas and property taxes than Illinois.

But still, not that big a burden? According to the “director of the state and local policy program at the University of Minnesota’s Humphrey Institute and an expert on transportation funding,” the average driver in Minnesota, using a 21-mpg vehicle to travel 15,000 miles a year, pays $203 to access state roads.

It may be an apples-to-oranges comparison and some may claim that, well, not buying gas just isn’t an option, but $203 is quite a bit less than $840 for that same Minnesotan to access cable television or $852 to use a cellphone.

So, today’s question: are those fair comparisons to make? (MinnPost)


About 16incheswestofpeoria

Former bicycle mechanic, current peruser of books, feeder of birds.
This entry was posted in Infrastructure and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Baby, you can tax my car (but my bicycle, really?)

  1. Fantastic article. I especially enjoyed the swingset/airline baggage analogy! 🙂 That attitude about cyclists not contributing to the paved infrastructure is prevalent out here in soggy NW Oregon, too.

  2. If we do not swing together, we shall all certainly swing alone–at least until that time that those who push, cease to do so.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s